skip to main | skip to sidebar

Jun 4, 2012

Your 2 hourly digest for U.S. News

U.S. News
Stories from NBC reporters around the country.
thumbnail Sandusky accusers must use real identities at trial, judge rules
Jun 4th 2012, 16:06

/

Former Penn State assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky, in an April 5 file photo.

By msnbc.com staff and news services

The judge in Jerry Sandusky’s child sex abuse trial ruled Monday that the alleged victims of the former Penn State assistant football coach will have to testify using their real names.

McKean County Senior Judge John Cleland also ruled that tweets or other electronic dispatches from reporters covering the trial, which begins Tuesday, will not be allowed, reversing an previous ruling.

At a pretrial hearing in Bellafonte, Pa., Cleland also resolved a dispute over research into potential jurors, rejecting a motion by Sandusky's lawyer to order the state attorney general's office to turn over information it has collected about potential jurors.


Jury selection is scheduled to begin Tuesday in Sandusky's trial on 52 counts that he sexually abused 10 boys over a 15-year period. Sandusky, 68, who remains confined in his home in State College, Pa., has repeatedly denied the charges.

Lawyers for five Sandusky accusers had requested that their clients be allowed to testify under pseudonyms.

Cleland rejected the motion, but pledged that the court would "cooperate when possible" to protect witness privacy and personal information.

"Arguably any victim of any crime would prefer not to appear in court, not to be subjected to cross-examination, not to have his or her credibility evaluated by a jury - not to put his name and reputation at stake," the judge wrote. "But we ask citizens to do that every day in courts across the nation."

The judge noted the sensitivity of the issue, and the efforts that both sides have made to protect the men to this point. But "once the trial begins, the veil must be lifted," he wrote.

In a statement provided to the Patriot News newspaper, lawyers Andrew Shubin and Justine Andronici, who represent multiple alleged Sandusky victims said they were “extremely disappointed” by the ruling.

"The victims in this case courageously came forward and provided extremely painful and personal information to investigators and prosecutors so that they could help protect children from further harm and exploitation,” the wrote. “The victims' experiences, the abuse they have suffered and its effects and their testimony at trial are certainly matters that are critical to the public interest. However, their personal identities are not."

Media organizations typically do not identify people who say they were sexually abused.

Cleland also denied a request by Sandusky's lawyer to order the attorney general's office to turn over information it has collected about potential jurors. Cleland said there was not enough evidence to warrant a hearing on the matter, and noted that prosecutors have said they have only done what a diligent defense attorney would do.

"Even if the commonwealth collected the information in this case in the manner the defense asserts and which the commonwealth denies, I do not believe that the information is constitutionally required to be turned over to the defense," Cleland wrote.

The basis for the defense request was an anonymous letter that claims to list the information prosecutors have collected.

"A motion filed by counsel must be supported by allegations of fact backed up with some credible basis to believe the allegations to be true," Cleland wrote. "Otherwise the court and counsel can be engaged in chasing chimeras."

Cleland, who was selected to preside over the Sandusky case after Centre County's judges recused themselves because of the defendant's connections to Penn State University, has not ruled on defense motions to have some or all of the charges thrown out. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court also has yet to rule on a motion by  filed late Friday by Sandusky's attorneys seeking a delay in the start of trial.

Cleland previously had said he would allow electronic communication, but not photographs or the recording or broadcasting of any verbatim account of the proceedings while court is in session.

Media groups, including The Associated Press, sought clarification on Friday, in response to which Cleland rescinded permission for any electronic communications from inside the Centre County courtroom.

"It is readily apparent from the allegations in the media's motion ... that the standard I applied in my definition is confusing to reporters, unworkable, and, therefore, likely unenforceable," the judge wrote.

The rules Cleland put in place are typical for Pennsylvania trials. He noted a state criminal procedure court rule that prohibits transmission of proceedings in session by phone, radio, TV, or "advanced communication technology."

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

More content from msnbc.com and NBC News:

Follow US News on msnbc.com on Twitter and Facebook

Pennsylvania father charged with killing wife, young daughters
Jun 4th 2012, 16:00

By msnbc.com staff and news services

INDIANA, Pa. -- A western Pennsylvania man has been jailed on charges he killed his two young daughters and his estranged wife at separate residences that were set ablaze.

Officials at the Indiana County Jail confirmed that Lewis Beatty, 40, was charged with three counts of criminal homicide, though online court records were not immediately available Monday, The Associated Press reported.

State troopers and Indiana County District Attorney Pat Dougherty planned to release additional details at a news conference Monday afternoon.


Coroner Michael Baker said the bodies were found at separate fires, which Dougherty identified as a mobile home in South Mahoning Township, where the two girls were found, and the other at a mobile home in East Mahoning Township, where their mother was found.

Neighbors Sally and Beryl Lydic said they knew the slain family and saw Beatty just before the attacks Friday, the Pittsburg Tribune-Review reported. Beatty was jailed without bond on Saturday.

"It's unimaginable," Sally Lydic told WTAE-TV in Pittsburgh. "It's unthinkable. I can't fathom what made him do that."

'His way or no way'
Ron Smail, who identified himself as the father of the woman and the grandfather of the two girls, told the Tribune-Review the girls were Sara Beatty, 6, and Amanda Beatty, 11. They were found dead after Beatty allegedly set fire to his own home in South Mahoning Township about 7 p.m. Friday.

"We always feared this would happen, but hoped it never would," Smail told The Tribune-Review. He described his estranged son-in-law as having a temper and said he had become more controlling of his family in the past several years. "It was always his way or no way," Smail said.

Watch US News videos on msnbc.com

Smail said his daughter, Christine Beatty, 33, was the suspect's estranged wife and had been slain inside the mobile home she had been renting near East Mahoning, about 15 minutes away, according to the Tribune-Review. That fire was reported about 8 p.m. Friday.

Smail said the coroner told him that all three victims bled to death from slash wounds to their throats.

The Lydics said they believe they heard shots fired to kill the girls' pets -- a pony, goat and dog -- before the children were slain. Beatty told the Lydics he'd been shooting groundhogs.

"He had a kind of little smirk on his face and said, 'You'd be surprised,' as he walked away," Beryl Lydic told the Tribune-Review.

The Presbyterian Church of Plumville, where the family attended church, posted the message: "We love you Chris Amanda and Sara" on a sign in front of the sanctuary.

Smail said his daughter and Beatty had separated and shared custody of the girls. He said Lewis Beatty was attempting to reconcile with Christine, who had turned down his invitation for a dinner date on Friday.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

More content from msnbc.com and NBC News:

Follow US News on msnbc.com on Twitter and Facebook

thumbnail Update: Graduation day tragedy: Ohio crash kills 4 teens
Jun 4th 2012, 08:15

/

Sean Egan embraces Brandon Davies as the Brunswick High School students mourn at the site of a fatal crash on Boston Road in Columbia Township on Sunday.

By msnbc.com staff and news services

A car carrying five teenagers went airborne as it sped over railroad tracks early Sunday and crashed, killing the 18-year-old driver hours before his high school graduation and two of his passengers, the Ohio State Highway Patrol said. 

A fourth teen, who was airlifted from the scene, died Monday at the Metrohealth Medical Center, the Plains Dealer reported Monday. 


Less than 13 hours after the crash, Brunswick High School students left empty seats covered with flowers at their graduation ceremony to remember driver Jeffrey Chaya and Kevin Fox, the student who died Monday. 

"It was very sad," Superintendent Michael Mayell said after the commencement ceremony at the University of Akron. "There were a lot of tears." 

The 2001 Chevrolet Cavalier was traveling at a high speed just after midnight when Chaya lost control in Columbia Township in northeast Ohio, troopers at the Elyria post said. The car went airborne and off the right side of the roadway, then swerved across the left side of the road, hit a ditch and tree, then flipped over, according to the troopers' report. 

Chaya, front-seat passenger Blake Bartchak, 17, and back-seat passenger Lexi Poerner, 16, died in the crash, according to The Chronicle-Telegram newspaper

Cleveland's Plain Dealer reported that Chaya and Bartchak were close friends, having first met in fourth grade when Chaya moved to the neighborhood. The two were together "constantly," Chaya's parents told the newspaper. 

Fox, a back-seat passenger, was thrown from the car into a ditch, troopers said. He was flown to Cleveland Metro Health Medical Center where he died Monday.

The fifth person in the car, identified by troopers as 17-year-old Julia Romito, was taken to Southwest General Hospital. The Plains-Dealer said reported she was in stable condition in surgical intensive care. 

/

Colin Curtis, left and Sobhit Haribakthi, seniors who graduated from Brunswick High School Sunday, grieve during a prayer service at St. Ambrose Church..

'Very popular students'
Fox and Chaya were called during the commencement, which included a moment of silence and comments about the tragic accident, Mayell said. More than 600 students graduated Sunday. 

Grief counselors were available to meet with students at the high school later in the day. Memorial services were held Sunday evening at a church and a performing arts center. 

 "We want to allow the families to grieve in peace, and do whatever we can to get through this very tragic situation," Mayell said. 

Troopers were still investigating the crash Sunday. They said the only confirmed factor was unsafe speed, although they were still calculating the car's estimated speed. 

/

Angel Smith, left, Samantha Aborub, and Charlotte Sigel, friends of Lexi Poerner and graduates of Brunswick High School in 2010, mourn during the candelight service for Brunswick High School victims.

Mayell has known Poerner's family for years, and said the students who were killed were well known at school, taking part in school activities and volunteering. 

"They were very popular students, very well-liked," Mayell said. "We've always been a very tight-knit community," he said. "It's one of those things that happens that I just don't get." 

Chaya, a wide receiver on the Brunswick High football team, was the kind of teen with a lot of "best friends," his mother Paula Chaya told the Plain Dealer.  

"He just loved being around his friends, and he had a ton of people who loved him," she told the newspaper. 

Chaya had posted Saturday on his Twitter account: "Weird to think graduation is tomorrow time does fly big time." 

On Saturday, graduating seniors at another northeast Ohio high school wore special red and black ribbons as a sign of unity and remembrance in the aftermath of the Feb. 27 Chardon school shootings that killed three students and wounded two others. 

The Associated Press contributed to this report. 

More content from msnbc.com and NBC News:

Follow US News on msnbc.com on Twitter and Facebook


You are receiving this email because you subscribed to this feed at blogtrottr.com.

If you no longer wish to receive these emails, you can unsubscribe from this feed, or manage all your subscriptions
 

TOP POPULAR NEWS Powered by Blogger